https://community.w2g.tv/t/how-to-use-watch2gether/736
Sunday, May 03, 2020
Notice of Appeal that Quotes Elie Mystal (Why not? He got the point.)
I had two cases in front of local district judge and GOP appointee David Cercone. They were both tossed when Byron Allen lost his case against Comcast. I'm appealing both of them. Unfortunately, no matter what Kanye says, my not friend President Trump has appointed all kinds of horrific judges to sit on the Third Circuit appeals courts. I know one of these judges, Peter Phipps, who has been written about in the past, openly sabotaged a former Fieldworks colleague of mine, He was promoted to the Third Circuit of Appeals. So, filing an appeal might be the same as throwing an anvil to a drowning man. But that's why they play em. Anyway, here's the notice of appeal for Elisabeth Wheeler and Pivot Physical Therapy.
vs. 2:18-cv-00221-DSC
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA
Philip Shropshire
Plaintiff
vs. 2:18-cv-00221-DSC
Elisabeth Wheeler, Pivot Physical Therapy
formerly known as
ALLEGHENY CHESAPEAKE
Defendants
NOTICE OF APPEAL
(On several Judge Cercones Judgments/Orders)
Comcast’s position holds African American litigants, and anyone else who falls under the protections of the 1866 Civil Rights Act, to a nearly impossible standard. Racist corporate executives don’t make a habit of walking around saying, “I would give that guy a contract if he weren’t black.” Even when they do think and act like that, they rarely commit such thoughts to an e-mail. Comcast wants black people to be able to prove a level of racism most white people won’t admit to. Under Comcast’s logic, all of their executives could have met with Allen while wearing MAGA hats and asked him which “s___hole country” his ancestors came from—and then simply told Allen they weren’t going to carry his network because of “economic” reasons.
Elie Mystal
https://www.thenation.com/article/society/scotus-comcast-discrimination/
Notice is hereby given that Philip Shropshire, with In Forma Pauperis already granted (Doc 2, May 15, 2018, ORDER granting 1 Motion for Leave to Proceed in forma pauperis. Signed by Judge David S. Cercone on 5/15/18.), Plaintiff in the above named case, hereby appeals to the United States Court of Appeals for the Circuit from (1) Document 37, March 17th, 2020, the opinion resolving 31 Defendant's Motion to Dismiss and (2) Document 38, March 17th 2020, the order granting 31 Defendant's Motion to Dismiss and (3) Document 39, March 17th 2020, final judgment pursuant to FRCP 58 and (4) Document 40, March 17th 2020, which is somewhat unclear but let's appeal it anyway at least until I'm more certain what it actually says. For some reason, PACER won't allow me to download it.
Submitted,
Philip Shropshire
4-15-2020
Certificate of Service
I certify that on the ______day of ______2019 this statement will be emailed or mailed to the Defendant's lawyers and a copy was either mailed or delivered to the clerk's office.
Signature:
Date:
Friday, April 17, 2020
Thing's I've written online that I'm proud of and are still there.
Probably the best thing I've ever written online is this. I argued that nothing could kill piracy and Harlan, a great writer who I miss, said that his lawsuit had something to do with stopping piracy. Harlan got a great settlement. Who was right? Go here to find out. Yes that answers the question. I'm very proud of my clever footnotes.
Why I Don't Support Harlan Ellison's KICK Internet Piracy Lawsuit
by Philip Shropshire
(Same review before editing.)
How to Get The Most From Your Kindle (Amazon Paperback)
I also wrote reviews of comics and graphic novels. You can find those reviews here and here.
Here I wrote reviews of a Star Trek graphic novel by David Brin, Great Green Lantern drawn by the late Seth Fisher and Frank Miller's Dark Knight Strikes Again
Reinventing Comics and Warren Ellis, the writer behind Netflix's Castlevania and Black Summer, comic "City of Silence"
Reviews of Alan Moore's Top Ten, Kingdom of the Wicked and Fallout
Tuesday, August 13, 2019
Test 3
Steve Jobs - How to Live before You Die
At his Stanford University commencement speech, Steve Jobs, CEO and co-founder of Apple and Pixar, urges us to pursue our dreams and see the opportunities in life's setbacks - including death itself.
Wednesday, August 07, 2019
Saturday, July 27, 2019
Wednesday, June 26, 2019
Trump Appointee Judge Peter Phipps is Openly Screwing Over the Race Discrimination Case Filed Against Fieldworks
One of the more horrible arguments made by "Bern or Busters" is that the courts don't matter. Well here's one of the new appointees from President Trump: Judge Peter Phipps. While technically he's not a member of the Federalist Society, people who are notoriously quiet on Brown v. Board of Education, Judge Peter Phipps might as well be. Both me and Justin used to work for Fieldworks. We're both suing the organization in the US federal courts over racial discrimination. Fieldworks claimed they fired Justin over "duplicate registrations", which they have yet to produce at any level. That's odd because we took photographs of all of our voter registrations so if they had evidence you would think they would have produced it. While Phipps has ruled in Justin's favor a few times most of the time he has made it impossible for him to win his case, mainly by the fact that Justin's motion for extension was granted, and then mysteriously cancelled. Luckily we have the judge's original order in writing that Judge Phipps conveniently forgot about. In fact, Phipps is running a clinic on how to kill a pro se complaint by moving the case entirely too fast and not granting common sense motions like an extension for discovery.
Yes Justin is interested in any pro bono legal help he can get.
Complete copy of what Justin sent to the Federal Courts.
Yes Justin is interested in any pro bono legal help he can get.
Complete copy of what Justin sent to the Federal Courts.
Plaintiff's Show of Cause or is it a fair
choice if the court makes me choose between my job/livelihood and a completely
arbitrary court date?
1. Introduction.
By the way, the answer posed by the
title here is "no". Also, and
let me be blunt, I no longer believe or think that Judge Peter Phipps is an
honest and objective judge, at least for plaintiffs in a civil rights case. He
was appointed by President Trump, famous for characterizing neo nazis and old
fashioned Klansmen as fine people, and known for being an overall racist and a
general loon. (He still won't apologize to the exonerated Central Park Five even
though they were cleared by DNA evidence and a confession by the real rapist.)
And at times I feel that Judge Phipps has given me that same kind of "very
fine" justice. He does no case analysis whatsoever (Shocking for a
Stanford man..). He just rules yay or no in, and here's a new word I learned,
"threadbare" briefs and sometimes just quotes the opposition
attorneys pretty much word for word. For example, if an appeals court ever
looks at this, and I'll probably ask them, how did I lose on the question of
specific jurisdiction? How did he determine that I didn't prove that
conclusively? Good luck finding it. That's what I would expect from a biased
right wing judge who hates these kinds of lawsuits.
2. Court and Other Side Told
Several Days Before Trial of My Unavailability.
So I suppose a judge with the gall
to force me to give up my job for a completely arbitrary court date wants to
fine me as well. Two quick arguments: One you're not supposed to fine IFP
plaintiffs. Or as it states multiple times in the circuit:
Shilala v. SCI Albion, et al., 2012 U.S.
Dist. LEXIS 95887, *7 (W.D. Pa. 2012) ("Alternative sanctions,
such as monetary penalties, are inappropriate with indigent parties.").
And of course I would argue that I
don't deserve any sanctions.
Or two: As soon as I found out on
Thursday what my schedule would be (See exhibit one.) I told the court to
reschedule. You had a full three days to cancel and reschedule. Please don't
try to pin the costs on me. I gave you plenty of time to make other
arrangements. You had three days. Take some responsibility for your own
actions.
2. The Trial Would Have Been A
Sham
Even if I had made the
"right" choice and lost my job over a completely arbitrary court date,
the trial wouldn't have been worth attending. Neither side had enough time to
do discovery. The discovery period shouldn't have started until the summary
judgment decisions were finalized. This is why the court cancelled the
defendant's subpoenas to depose because they weren't timely, unless the court
has changed its mind again to help the defendants. Who knows.
The court also seems to be
forgetting something in its own statement. Here it is again (Document 101).
On April
24, 2019 , this Court entered a second pretrial order at ECF
No. 67. Therein, a jury trial in this matter was scheduled for today, June 10, 2019 . The trial
schedule was further discussed during a telephone status conference on May 21,
2019 and a pretrial conference on May 31, 2019. On June 7, 2019 , Plaintiff filed a motion
to stay that was denied the same day, re-establishing for the record that a
jury trial in this matter was scheduled to begin today, June 10, 2019 . ECF No. 96. In spite
of the well-established trial date in this matter, Plaintiff failed to appear.
The court conveniently forgets its
own May 21st (Document 81) order where it promised this.
Subpoena Handed to a Person at My
House and Not Me and Motion to Extend the Discovery by 60 Days, ECF No. 72, are
granted. The appropriate order will follow.
So common sense would suggest that
I didn't have to prepare for a trial on June 10. A fair judge, even if he meant
something other than the plain reading of the words (A reasonable person could
conclude that the motion for the extension was granted. Unless the court wanted
Discovery to extend beyond a jury verdict.) would have chosen to honor the extension
and cancel all post discovery motions (like motions in limine) until discovery
was completed. Just out of a sense of fairness and to avoid prejudice. But not
our Phipps.
3. Poulis Factors Exonerate Me.
I don't write this for the judge. I
no longer think he's objective. I think Phipps is a federalist society hack. He
certainly doesn't deserve a promotion to the appeals court. He doesn't even
deserve to be on the bench. I write this for the appeals court.
Here's a list of the Poulis Factors
from Hildebrand vs. Allegheny
County :
(1) the extent of the party’s personal responsibility; (2)
the prejudice to the adversary caused by the failure to meet scheduling orders
and respond to discovery; (3) a history of dilatoriness; (4) whether the
conduct of the party or the attorney was willful or in bad faith; (5) the
effectiveness of sanctions other than dismissal, which entails an analysis of
alternative sanctions; and (6) the meritoriousness of the claim or defense.
I will answer these one at a time..
One (extent). I just started the
job a month ago and unlike a federal lifetime court appointment I have to
perform and can not take off three days whenever I want to do court things. At
least not if I want to keep my job. I got my schedule Thursday. I told them Friday.
I warned the court that this could happen and made many attempts to get
extensions. (An appeals court can take a look at the minutes of our hearings. I
made many objections.) Two (prejudice): The court date was completely arbitrary
and needed to be set aside according to Judge Phipps own order granting the
extension. The other side hadn't even completed discovery yet. 3.
(dilatoriness). Not only do I have a habit of showing up, when I'm not working,
but I've had to put statements back into the record that the court tried to
illegally throw out, claiming wildy that there were certain Federal Rules of
Civil Procedure that I wasn't allowed to use. I simply lacked the ability to be
in two places at once for the trial. Also one incident of lateness wouldn't cut
as it states in Burden v. Yate 1981: "missing one deadline as a
result of a miscommunication--simply doesn't create a record of intentional
delay." People who have been found wanting or in violation of the Poulis
factors are people who have ignored their cases for several months to several
years. I haven't done that and gave the court a three day warning that I would
be unavailable for, quite frankly, a fraudulent trial. 4. (willful and bad
faith). Am I at fault for the schedule given to me by my boss? Am I acting in
bad faith when I immediately tell you about it the day after so that you can
you cancel the date and save your money? I think not. 5. (sanctions). I don't
believe sanctions are warranted. I'm not at fault. No one should have to choose
between their job and an arbitrary court date, that should have never happened
under the judge's own orders (see document 81). 6. (meritoriousness). I already
beat a summary judgment motion which never should have been held before
discovery started and ended! I was told when I was fired that I was guilty of
duplicate registrations. These registrations have never been produced as
evidence. If I ever got a full discovery period, not one where I had to
concentrate on trying to keep the case from ending while attempting to do
discovery while working or looking for work, then I'm sure I could learn
whether this evidence exists or not. Judge Phipps has done everything possible,
including ignoring one of his own orders, to make sure that I could never find
out for sure. Judge Peter Phipps is really an active member of the defense, not
a neutral or objective "judge".
4. Conclusion.
One of the most horrifying things
Phipps has said is that he doesn't believe, because of a Supreme Court
decision, in the right to discovery. Now I haven't read a lot of cases, but if
that was the norm of the federal courts (And let me guess: rich people and
corporations would get full discovery and poor people and minorities wouldn't,
kind of like now.) the federal courts would turn into the People's Court. There
can be no trials or real justice without real discovery. The extension I asked
for was minor and should have been granted, and was. I'll let the appeals court
do its job. One final note: any objective look at the 100 or so documents filed
in this case, including my own statement of facts, should be ample proof that I
have attempted to prosecute my own case. I would hope that would be clear.
Update: Justin was wrong about saying that Phipps based his decision on no right to discovery on a Supreme Court decision. Apparently, that's just what Phipps thinks. Justin disputes that he was informed that the extension was cancelled. Only way to be sure though is to take a listen to the court audio, but Phipps statement definitely contradicts what was written on May 21st. Here's the court statements published by Phipps himself.
Friday, April 19, 2019
Reminder: I can now self publish paperbooks on Amazon. Even do comics.
I got this in an email because I've already self published a few things. This is a reminder. I plan to use these tools very very soon.
|
|
Saturday, February 16, 2019
#TheBlacklist Had no idea General Shiro was real. Also hope that insects can't blossom and grow inside your body.
As horrible as that imagery was, something the Joker could take notes on and emulate its just so bad, what the main villain was fighting against was actually much much worse. Large scale pesticide adoption kind of like what the Trump administration is pushing for. More information about General Shiro. He was the Japanese version of Mengele. Maybe worse. Known as "The Devil's Doctors". Not sure if he ever did that insect thing or if it's even possible. Shock ending: The US recruited the general into our own bioweapons program. He lived out his final years in the USA. He could have been your neighbor in some quiet suburb. Great episode.
By the way, the case against Elisabeth Wheeler, attorney Donna Glover and Pivot Physical Therapy continues.
By the way, the case against Elisabeth Wheeler, attorney Donna Glover and Pivot Physical Therapy continues.
Monday, January 14, 2019
Long Intimate Imaginary Relationship with Elizabeth Warren Threatened by AOC on Temptation Island
This is why I'm in a long term and intimate imaginary relationship with Elizabeth Warren. She also excels in these kinds of settings and she's right. OTOH I'm on temptation island with AOC, tempting me her with nearly nekkid island dance, wearing scant black widow/catwoman leather and a shimmering rorshack mask...I-I must say no. Oh no she's quoting Promethea, Black Summer, Deep Space Nine and Greg Egan as I start running toward her, heart racing, my manhood stirred...
The government should be open. Federal workers are not pawns. They should be doing their jobs and getting paid for their jobs. It’s a leadership problem not just with the Trump administration, but with Mitch McConnell. pic.twitter.com/Ug4MLZvTkV— Elizabeth Warren (@ewarren) January 14, 2019
Saturday, November 03, 2018
Newest court filing against Fieldsworks, Chris Gallaway, and Zachary Reider, worst canvass director in the world and: Why aren't these guys in jail?
I think its the white privilege thing again. Because I'm pretty certain that as a black man I would be in jail for doing the same thing.
Clearly, Fieldworks and Zachary Reider, probably under the instruction of Chris Gallaway or other managers (Need discovery to pin that down absolutely...) clearly broke the State of Pennsylvania's rule against quotas for voter registration forms. What's worse they used that standard in a discriminatory way by making sure that blacks had to reach a higher quota. Anyway, here's the latest court filing where I don't mention any of that stuff but its still annoying.
10-31-18
Clearly, Fieldworks and Zachary Reider, probably under the instruction of Chris Gallaway or other managers (Need discovery to pin that down absolutely...) clearly broke the State of Pennsylvania's rule against quotas for voter registration forms. What's worse they used that standard in a discriminatory way by making sure that blacks had to reach a higher quota. Anyway, here's the latest court filing where I don't mention any of that stuff but its still annoying.
Brief Response
to Defendant's Sept. 26th Statement
1. I think I described their
statement of Sept. 26th as being "weak tea" to opposing council and I
stand by this.
2. But I do want to offer a very
brief response. So here's a few points:
3.
I kind of wish I had been granted the original extension that I asked
for. I'm answering this within 35 days because the defendant's statements are
part of dispositive motion. But I still would like more time. I feel this
affects my case in a very negative way. For example the deadline for responding
to this brief and the brief in the other case on the exact same day. Or today.
Not fair.
4. All of the problems that
Defendants complain about can be solved with an amended complaint. This is
where I use the specific examples of what I meant in the original complaint in
the following response briefs in the amended complaint. I can also make sure
that I clearly state what Section 1981 does but I assumed since yinz guys were
lawyers that you already knew. I just need an afternoon or two to do that.
Would gladly do it if necessary.
5. Or the court could use the
"common sense' instruction that its supposed to use in 12 b 6 cases and
assume that the Defendants already understand what they have to rebut, by now
(such as direct testimony that Zachary Reider is a racist by five black persons
and possibly one white employee as well.) and we can simply move on to
discovery. I think I used the phrase "obscenely obtuse" in another
legal document. That would be the case here if there was a demand for an
amended complaint but I could still write one. Might take two afternoons who
knows. They know by now what has to be rebutted.
6. Its clear that Zachary Reider is
an employer or proxy of an employer which means that he's the kind of guy that
has to abide by Section 1981. Or I was fired by a ghost. Some kind of imaginary
being. There were no other managers at Fieldworks at the time.
7. I don't have to prove a prima
facie case at this stage. See the appeals court decision Sandra Connelly v.
Lane Construction Corporation:
It is thus worth reiterating that, at least for purposes
of pleading sufficiency, a complaint need not establish a prima facie case in
order to survive a motion to dismiss.6 A prima facie case is “an evidentiary
standard, not a pleading requirement,” Swierkiewicz v. Sorema, N.A., 534 U.S.
506, 510 (2002), and hence is “not a proper measure of whether a complaint
fails to state a claim.” Fowler v. UPMC Shadyside, 578 F.3d 203, 213 (3d Cir.
2009)
8. We may ask for a hearing so that
these issues can be ironed out.
Respectfully submitted,
Philip Shropshire
Signature
Certificate of
Service
I have mailed out
this statement on Oct. 31st, 2018
to the court by way of UPS. I will email a copy of this statement to opposing
counsel in the next day or two.
Wednesday, September 05, 2018
Court Response Where I Call Pivot Physical Therapy Supervisor Elisabeth Wheeler and her counsel Donna Glover Inveterate Liars
I call Elisabeth Wheeler and her attorney Donna Glover inveterate liars because they lie all the time. In fact, they lie, kind of like our current orange skinned president, when they really don't have to lie. I think its just their first option. Anyway, when I have more time I'll add to this. Here's the latest that I sent to the court.
8-29-18
Philip
Shropshire
Pro
Se
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT
COURT FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT
|
Plaintiff,
vs.
Elisabeth
Wheeler
Pivot
Physical Therapy
Defendants
|
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
|
Case
No.: No. 2 18 cv 221 DSC
Plaintiff's
Response to Defendant's Aug 8th Statement, Local Rule 7E argument for August
20th extension and query to the Court: Does the Court want me to write an
Amended Complaint?
|
Preface
While I'm
limited by the demands of my very grueling physical job -- I walk three to five
miles a day in 90 degree plus heat several days a week (With Pgh hills and
steps its not unlike being on a stairmaster for three hours straight while in a
sauna...) -- and the fact that I'm now
juggling two lawsuits instead of one -- I believe I have a right under Rule 7
to file a response within 21, or even 35 days on a dispositive motion. But just
to play it safe I think 21 days ends on August 29th. And there was so much that
was wrong with Donna Glover's August 8th statement to this court that it quite
frankly demands a response. There has been no response to the extension that I
asked for or the motion to strike asked for by defendant's counsel. So I
usually assume the worst and that 21 or 35 days is all that I get. But I would
love that extension under local Rule 7e so I could be more thorough and
scrutinize every dot and every t of Donna Glover's August 8th statement. Unless
the court were to grant my wish and strip both PHRA and Title VII (They're not
needed. You can do retaliation and disparate treatment and mixed motive cases
just fine under Section 1981. In fact you can do more. I'm not sure why I'm
supposed to by angry about that. Or even care.)
I'm going
to briefly address three arguments. One, we're going to argue that my August
20th motion for an extension is clearly allowed under Local Rule 7E. Two, we
believe that the Reyes vs. Autozone Inc. case is the most on point case
for going forward where Title VII and PHRA were time barred but the valid
Section 1981 claim continued and where the plaintiff was allowed discovery to
attempt to prove his case. (Decisions that weren't rendered until after
Discovery and only at the summary judgment stage. ) Three, we're going to talk
a little bit more about civility and explain the factual basis behind our meat
and potatoes disparate treatment case. They're overwhelming and are, for the
most part, already proven by the Defendant's own 20 page EEOC statement. My
arguments aren't "conclusionary" but based on the facts within the
Defendant's own very flawed statements and my own experiences at Pivot.
So. Let
us begin again.
I.
Local Rule 7E allows for a one time extension for all parties. Let's quote the rule here:
E. Stipulations. The parties, without Court approval, may
file a stipulation one time which extends for a period not to exceed 45 days
from the original due date the time for filing either an answer to a complaint
or a motion pursuant to Fed. R.
Civ. P. 12
There
really shouldn't be any problem with me asking for such a request. I don't even
ask for the full 45 days.
II.
We have no problem with Title VII or the PHRA being stripped. Section 1981
claim is still valid and relies on the same methodology and the case can
proceed. I
thought that should be in bold.
A.) When I was back on the debate team in college
(eons ago) we used a simple technique. Any argument that wasn't challenged by
the other side was a win for us. The case that wasn't brought up or challenged
in any way was Reyes vs. Autozone Inc, where the Title VII and PHRC were
time barred but the Section 1981 claim was valid and it continued. That's also the case with Ejikeme v. PA
Dept of Transportation. Not the exact same case law with Ejikeme but
the common sense approach of barring claims that aren't allowed and allowing
claims that are valid, like Section 1981 in this case, to continue. It should
be noted that those conclusions were made in that case during the summary
judgment phase and after Discovery and not beforehand. Go figure. Or you can go
to the online database of Casetext and find 1000 plus cases featuring motions
denied or motions affirmed. This isn't really a controversial view. Yes we know
defendants take a crack at this in pages 9 though but they fail horribly. These
issues can be fully addressed if my Aug. 20th extension is granted.
III.
Let's talk briefly about "Civility" and why I think Attorney Donna
Glover and her client Pivot Physical Therapy Supervisor Elizabeth Wheeler are
both inveterate liars.
This has
to be discussed a bit more fully.
A.) Let's
address these concerns about "civility". Like in most writing
people tend to bury the really interesting stuff in the footnotes. Here's one
such statement although I'm not sure if a pro se plaintiff can effectively be
threatened with sanctions"
Throughout the course of his Opposition, Shropshire referred to the undersigned
defense counsel as “arrogant,” “kinda dumb,” and “lackluster, poorly briefed
clowns.” (Shropshire Opp. at 5, 10). Shropshire also suggested that the
undersigned defense counsel are incapable of reading, are “silly and full of
lies,” and are “desperate.” (Id. at 10, 16) Although Shropshire is not a member of the bar, and
thus not held to the same standards of conduct, he should nonetheless conduct
himself before this Court in a manner that respects and treats everyone with
civility, including the Defendants and their counsel. Counsel for Defendants
therefore requests that Shropshire refrain from this behavior going
forward.
Yeah,
well, respect is earned not granted. Look, its not that I mind that you lie to
me. Its clear that you and your client think that I'm a dumb darkie who doesn't
know when white people are lying to his face. Fair enough. What I find, uh,
well, "kinda dumb" and "arrogant" is lying to the court.
This judge is learned but even if he weren't he has researchers and other legal
minds to help guide him. So you should never lie about cases that Judge Cercone
actually worked on. For example, in a paragraph that is kind of one big lie in
itself (More on that paragraph later if I get that extension.) you state this
on page 17 of your August 8th statement:
Second, case law from throughout the Third Circuit, and
this Court in particular, is replete with examples of complaints that were
factually deficient on their face and were dismissed as a matter of law prior
to discovery. Of course, many of these cases were employment discrimination
cases and involved pro se plaintiffs, some of which were decided by this very
Court. See, e.g., Koger v. Robert Half International, 247 Fed. Appx. 349 (3d Cir.
2007) (affirming Judge Cercone’s decision to grant defendant’s motion to
dismiss pro se plaintiff’s employment discrimination claim before discovery);
Yet
Cercone wrote a case management order that included Discovery. There was an
exhibit plan that was as released. This is one of Cercone's orders, which you
can read at the PACER datebase.
DISCOVERY AND PRETRIAL DEADLINES IT IS FURTHER ORDERED
that compliance with Local Rule 16.1 shall be completed as follows: 1) The
parties shall move to amend the pleadings or add new parties by January 9, 2006 . 2) All fact and expert discovery shall be completed by February 7, 2006 . All written discovery shall be initiated in sufficient
time to permit responses to be completed and depositions to be taken in
compliance with all applicable deadlines. 3) Plaintiff’s pretrial narrative
statement shall be filed on or before March 9, 2006 , and comply with Local Rule
16.1.4A. Case 2:05 -cv-00850-DSC Document 14 Filed 10/07/05 Page 1 of 5 -2- Counsel shall specify all material facts
to be proved at trial and identify all exhibits to be used in the plaintiff’s
case-in-chief. Proof of facts not specified or exhibits not identified may be
excluded at trial upon objection or by the court sua sponte. 4) Defendants’
pretrial narrative statement shall be filed on or before April 7, 2005 , and comply with Local Rule 16.1.4B. Counsel shall
specify all material facts to be proved at trial and identify all exhibits to
be used in the defendants’ case-in-chief. Proof of facts not specified or exhibits
not identified may be excluded at trial upon objection or by the court sua
sponte.
5) Counsel shall confer and complete the attached pretrial
stipulation on or before April 17, 2006 . 6) All dispositive motions shall
be filed on or before May 17, 2006 .
And if
you look at Exhibit Two you find that Koger was actually deposed! This would
suggest a discovery period. It also means that defendant's counsel is either
incompetent or she told a big fat lie. Probably both. Perhaps this is an
example of someone being "poorly briefed" or "lackluster"
Now, its one thing to want more discovery after you've been granted a discovery
period but its another thing to entirely claim that no discovery period ever
occurred. And I'm pretty sure that's a lie. How is that not a lie? And as long
as you and your clients lie, I'm going to call out your lies.
B.)
The Defendant's EEOC statement, written by Attorney Donna Glover, is full of
lies.
This is
Exhibit One. I'm putting the whole 20 pages into the record. Here are just the lies on page 2 of that statement.
Some of my claims can be proven with a discovery period. Some are already
proven by the lack of any progressive discipline record. Why are lies
important? Because, according to analysis by the Boston Employment Blog and
written jury instructions for Title VII and Section 1981 discrimination cases:
"... “the trier of fact can
reasonably infer from the falsity of the explanation that the employer is
dissembling to cover up a discriminatory purpose.” The Court further stated
that “once the employer’s justification has been eliminated, discrimination may
well be the most likely alternative explanation, especially since the employer
is in the best position to put forth the actual reason for its decision.”
Now this
is just page two of that 20 page statement but Donna Glover and Elizabeth
Wheeler lied about me being late for work on my second day. I was given a span
to arrive between 7 and 7 15 am. I arrived in the lot by 7 15 am or possibly 7
14 am. The vehicle was long gone. I didn't even catch it pulling out. I got
there on time. But there are cameras and
I would be happy to look at the tape. Something I wouldn't want to do if I was
lying. We need discovery for that. Both Donna Glover and Elizabeth Wheeler are
lying about me violating the dress code. I wore sweatpants underneath my
approved of slacks mainly because I used to walk home in 10 degree weather and
didn't want to freeze off my essential bits. That's not a violation. Both Donna
Glover and Elizabeth Wheeler are lying when they say I violated rules about
submitting time sheets. According to April Bibars you could do it one of two
ways: you could submit the sheets electronically or you could hand deliver
them. I tried electronic delivery at first. But the Pivot computer systems
couldn't read my documents even though my home computers could. But I never
violated any orders by doing it that way. Under section five on page two, at
least one of those occasions was when they sent me to the wrong address which
made me late although without discovery how they define "late" or
whether white workers were treated to the same standards isn't actually clear.
(The other one was when they didn't tell me when my work day started. Usually I
have to call the day before.) Also keep in mind the progressive discipline
that they have. It wasn't used in just about every one of these situations.
You're supposed to use it if I gamble on the premises or bring a gun to work. A verbal warning, then a
written one. I got nuthin'. (Their suggested use of the progressive discipline
rules.) On page two, third graph, that begins "On at least one
occasion" both Donna Glover and Elizabeth Wheeler are lying when they
claim "Mr. Shropshire disappeared during the workday". You know why
that's a lie? Because I usually carried two cell phones on me. They knew where
I was at all times and could reach me at all times. Sometimes trips were
cancelled. I usually knew while driving. Hey its the future. You're never away
from "work" with cell phones. I've been called while in the bathroom.
They also mention, on page 5, that I committed the crime of going to the
grocery while forgetting to mention that I had a lunch break and had to
occasionally use the bathroom. The East End Coop is actually underneath Pivot.
These are just awful dimwitted lies uttered by, I'm presuming, a desperate Elizabeth Wheeler and sanctioned
by an equally desperate Donna Glover. Frankly, they'll be disproved within 90
seconds of a deposition with any other driver. I just hope I can get a discovery
period.
And
that's just pages two and five. So when I say this in my initial complaint:
11. Plaintiff believes he was fired for his race for a
host of pretextual reasons including but not limited to: lying in wait, post
hoc rationalizations, using a hypercritical standard not applied to white
workers, treating white workers better
and holding them to a lesser standard, false information in defendant's EEOC
position statement and a whole bunch of "weaknesses, implausibilities,
inconsistencies, incoherencies or contradictions" as written by Ruth Bader
Ginsburg, Hardy v. S.F. Phosphates Ltd. Co. , 185 F.3d 1076, 1080 (10th Cir.
1999). We plan to save Pivot's unsigned evaluation, a two page parade of
pretext, presented to the EEOC but never before seen by me, for either a
rebuttal or perhaps even an amended complaint.
These
aren't "conclusionary". These are facts that I derive from Pivot
Physical Therapy's own EEOC statement, which I described as "silly and
full of lies". I stand by that statement. And whenever Donna Glover or
Elizabeth Wheeler lies, whether its court statements or to my face, I'm going
to call them liars. To their faces. I don't know if lawyers can be sanctioned
for lying all the time. Perhaps the judge would consider that
"redundant" and "moot". After seeing Donna Glover in action
I would get that.
Conclusion:
I would
also hope that the court would see that there are enough sufficient facts about
the case to proceed to a discovery period. I was using shorthand for pretext
before in describing the incidents. I hope this adds a bit more detail and
depth.
Just for
the record these are the kinds of pretext that are evident from Pivot's EEOC
statement and my own observations:
Unattainable goals (Being on time
when the destination is wrong.)
No opportunity to finish work
improvement plan.
Suspect documentation (Using desk
files and unsigned evaluations to prove alleged work deficiencies that were
never mentioned to me when I worked there.)
Papering the file and
hypercritical (A dirty shirt? Really? That's an offense to be fired for? Or
just niggers?)
Failure to follow policies as
typically applied (Take Pivot's progressive discipline policy, please.)
False statements to EEOC and other
agencies (Take Pivot's EEOC statement, please.)
Not my job (To get the addresses
right.)
Reasons just make no sense (You
supplied the wrong address not me. That's what made me late. Whatever that
means.)
Lying in wait
Post Hoc rationalizations (Didn't
receive a single client complaint while working at Pivot now there's a bunch of
them. Contradicted even by their own unsigned evaluation.)
Weaknesses, implausibilities,
incoherencies or contradictions (See all of the above.)
Any one
of these should beat summary judgment and get me a jury trial. But its not just
the one thing. This case is wide and deep even before discovery. And if a shark
like Cordes or O Brien were to get this case in front of a jury then your
company is looking at extinction. Those are just the kinds of pretext I have
time to list.
Are these
enough facts for the court or is an amended complaint still needed? I can't
tell if Attorney Donna Glover is being purposely obtuse or is just dim wittedly
obtuse, or some awful combination of
incompetence or stupidity or if she's just lying, yet again, when she says
there are not facts in the case. Ms. Glover lies so much of course so who knows.
I respect the competence and intelligence of this court and this judge. I have
always been treated more than fairly. I have no respect for the aptitude or
competence of Ms. Donna Glover, who as Pivot's attorney made their case much
worse with that EEOC statement full of lies and error.
Respectfully
submitted,
Signed:
Philip
Shropshire
pshropshire@yahoo.com
www.threeriversonline.com
Sunday, August 05, 2018
Friday, June 01, 2018
Full Initial Complaint of Philip Shropshire v. Elisabeth Wheeler and Pivot Physical Therapy
So it looks like this case is beginning to start. Generally, its never about the work where I lose these jobs. Usually it has to do with being uppity. Or perceived as being uppity. That usually means a black person speaking in complete sentences. Anyway, I'm thinking of using Elisabeth of Pivot Therapy, Zachary Reider of Fieldworks (A company whose behavior during the lawsuit has been nothing short of bizarre. It looks like they're trying to ignore the civil suit and risk a default judgement. I'm okay with that....) and Donald Trump as examples of really bad bosses. They could all be described as insecure (Elisabeth Wheeler was too cowardly to even show me my evaluation. I didn't see it until I read Pivot's EEOC statement.), mediocre, dimwitted sociopaths. Just my opinion. And, if the revolution comes, I truly believe that the at will system should be replaced with just cause and progressive discipline.
Anyway here's the initial complaint which was finally filed and accepted by the court.
IN THE UNITED STATES
DISTRICT COURT FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA
Philip
Shropshire Civil Action No:
vs.
Elisabeth
Wheeler
Pivot
Physical Therapy (Formerly known as Allegheny Chesapeake)
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PRO SE CIVIL COMPLAINT
1. Jurisdiction
The
jurisdiction of this court is invoked pursuant to the Civil Rights Act of 1866,
42 U.S. Code § 1981, Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the amended
Civil Rights Act of 1991, as well as Pennsylvania's Human Relations Act or the PHRA.
We are filing under the counts of discrimination based on race.
2.
The plaintiff has satisfied all procedural and administrative prerequisites to
sue under the PHRA, Title VII and 42 U.S. Code § 1981, He received his right to
sue letter on Nov. 23, 2017 from the EEOC for the permission to sue Elizabeth
Wheeler and Allegheny Chesapeake rehabilitation, since bought out by Pivot
Rehabilitation. The complaint also is
also timely under Section 1981 which gives you four years to file a complaint
after the termination date. (May 2016).
3.
Defendants Elizabeth Wheeler and Fieldworks are employers under Title
VII, PHRA and 42 USC 1981. It's also a defense they never attempted in their
somewhat voluminous 20 page statement that was sent to the EEOC. (Please place
that into the record here as well. I understand there are perjury laws that can
be enforced under this venue. And they shall be.)
II Venue
4.
We believe the venue is proper because defendants have resided and/or conducted
business in this judicial district and/or because all of the acts giving rise
to the claims set forth herein occurred in this judicial district.
III. Parties
5.
Plaintiff Philip Shropshire is an African American male who resides at 740 Franklin Avenue , Pgh. PA 15221.
6.
Defendant Pivot Technology have an office at 7501 Penn Avenue , Pgh. PA 15208.
Defendant Elisabeth Wheeler works at that office, last time I checked
online. We are naming Elisabeth Wheeler as a defendant and we're suing her in
both her professional and personal capacity.
IV. Factual Background
7.
Paragraphs one through six are incorporated herein by reference as though set
in full.
8.
I received an offer letter Feb. 8 2016 . from the then Allegheny Chesapeake which also
included an employee handbook. My last day of employment was May 31st, 2016 . I was hired as kind of an in house taxi driver
who delivered patients to and from the Penn Avenue clinic and back to their homes. The employment
handbook I was given with my acceptance letter included a four prong test. In
their voluminous 20 page letter to the EEOC it is clear that I never reached
sanction three and its debatable that I ever reached sanction two or in many
cases even sanction one. What's also missing from their EEOC statement is that
I successfully completely anywhere from 70 to 100 delivery trips without error
or complaint. My time sheets, which proves this, are mysteriously missing from
their exhibit list. We will certainly ask for them in any discovery process. I
believe I was the lone African American that worked for them in any capacity.
9.
I believe I was fired over the phone, always a classy move and never leads to
lawsuits, about a week after May 31st, for an incident that was clearly the
fault of Elisabeth Wheeler and the then named Allegheny Chesapeake. Wheeler, or
one of her employees, gave me the wrong address for a client and then blamed me
for being late! In fact, after reading through Pivot's EEOC statement its
probable that their motivations were premeditated and had nothing to with my
work record. Or even that event. In fact, to put this in a non legal way, I was
most likely fired for being an uppity negro, which I'm proud of, but which I
also don't think is grounds for legal termination under prevailing civil rights
law.
Count 1
Title VII, PHRA and Section 1981
Race Discrimination
10.
Plaintiff incorporates by reference the allegations in Paragraphs 1 through 9.
11.
Plaintiff believes he was fired for his race for a host of pretextual reasons
including but not limited to: lying in wait, post hoc rationalizations, using a
hypercritical standard not applied to white workers, treating white workers better and holding
them to a lesser standard, false information in defendant's EEOC position
statement and a whole bunch of "weaknesses, implausibilities,
inconsistencies, incoherencies or contradictions" as written by Ruth Bader
Ginsburg, Hardy v. S.F. Phosphates Ltd. Co. , 185 F.3d 1076, 1080 (10th Cir.
1999). We plan to save Pivot's unsigned evaluation, a two page parade of
pretext, presented to the EEOC but never before seen by me, for either a
rebuttal or perhaps even an amended complaint.
12.
WHEREFORE, the Plaintiff Philip Shropshire demands judgment pursuant to Title
VII, Section 1981 and the PHRA as follows, included but not limited to:
- That Defendants be
required to compensate Plaintiff for the full value of wages he would have
received had it not been for the Defendant's illegal treatment of
Plaintiff with interest since his termination in May 2016.
- That Defendants be
required to provide Plaintiff with front pay if the court decides
reinstatement is not feasible. (I would only want to be reinstated under
contract with clear definitions of work responsibilities, and with an
enshrined code of progressive discipline (enforced this time.), as well as
clear First Amendment Rights, not to mention compensatory damages being
paid upfront.)
- That Defendants be
required to compensate Plaintiff for lost benefits, including profit
sharing and/or pension benefits until Plaintiff’s normal retirement date.
That defendants be awarded compensatory damages of at least $35,000 or an
amount to be determined at trial.
- That Defendants be
ordered to pay, each, $1.5 million dollars in punitive damages or an
amount to be determined at trial.
- That Pro Se
Plaintiff be awarded against Defendant the costs and expenses of this
litigation.
- That Plaintiff be
granted such further legal and equitable relief as the Court may deem just
and proper.
Summary
13.
Plaintiff incorporates paragraphs 1 through 12 as if fully restated.
14.
I look forward to seeing the rebuttal by Defendants. It will be thoroughly
debunked, probably line by line.
Respectfully
submitted,
Pro
Se Plaintiff Philip Shropshire
(I edited out my personal address and phone number.)
2
21 2018
*Note
to the court again: We will send papers to defendants to waive service within
the next week or so.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





